Skip to content

Why is it so difficult to free India of manual scavenging?

December 22, 2010

Guest post by BEZWADA WILSON

Safai karamcharis from across India declared their liberation at a function in Delhi on 20 December

Over the years, there have been many changes in the Safai Karamchari Andolan movement. The biggest change we have seen has been in the safai karamchari community’s outlook. There was a time when safai karamcharis were ashamed to admit they did manual scavenging. It was not uncommon for even family members to be unaware that someone was involved in the practice of manual scavenging.

But the community started discussing the issue threadbare and the silence over manual scavenging was broken. They came together and organised themselves on a national platform with the single focus of eradicating manual scavenging. As the state and the judiciary began hearing our voices, we began to break the chains of caste and patriarchy.

We gathered the courage to burn the baskets we once used to collect human excreta in. We began knocking the doors of the district magistrates to implement the 1993 Act of Parliament that outlawed manual scavenging. Ideally the DM should have been approaching the safai karamcharis and helping them leave the practice. It’s an irony that we have had to got to the DMs to make them aware of the Act they should have been making us aware of! In doing so, however, we have been strengthening the functioning of the Indian democracy. In the twenty first century, safai karamcharis are making stronger the pillars of Indian democracy!

Over the past few months, 1,260 enumerators, who are from within the safai karamchari community, have conducted a massive survey documenting the prevalence of manual scavenging. The community, in many places, has decided to leave the practice on its own. People are still coming out and acknowledging that they are into the work and resolving, trying and managing to leave it.

The changes that have taken place in the community have been reflected at the legislative and judicial levels. Thanks to the work of many intellectuals and activists, the centenary year celebrations of Babasaheb Ambedkar in 1991 resulted in a slew of measures for Dalits.

The Eradication of Manual Scavenging & Dry Latrine (Abolition) Act came into force in 1993. But the aim of the Act has not been fulfilled even today. On 20 December 2003, exactly seven years ago, the Safai Karamchari Andolan and 13 others filed a petition in the Supreme Court to make the state and central government and their bodies implement the Act.

To begin with, the state governments wouldn’t submit the affidavits the Supreme Court asked them to. Even after the Supreme Courts reprimands, sevem principal secretaries had to be summoned to the court for them to take cognisance of the case! In the affidavits submitted, all of them denied that manual scavenging was prevalent under their jurisdiction.

So the onus of proving that it existed fell upon us, the victims, victimizing us further. We started collecting data along with photographic and video evidence in several states. As a result of such evidence we would submit in Supreme Court, the states would simply go and demolish those dry latrines, and reported back to the court that these didn’t exist! This became a strategy for us: we started collecting more material and submitting it.

In seven years the case has seen eight judges, including two chief justices, preside over the hearings. The process has been slow and cumbersome. The last hearing was in November when the court mulled over the issue of whether it can direct state governments who had not notified the Act to do so. The next hearing is on January 11.

We have used two orders passed by the SC in 2008 to expedite the process. We took the orders around to district magistrates and ask them to implement those orders and demolish dry latrines in their districts.

In 2005, we went around states demolishing dry latrines. We would be prevented from doing so, in response to which we said that when the government denies the existence of these dry latrines how could we be demolishing them? This way we forced governments to act. The most notable case was that of a dry latrine inside the Nizamabad court complex in Hyderabad!

Just to demolish a dry latrine and liberate a safai karamchari, why should it need an order from the highest court of the land? Can’t the government simply implement an Act it has itself passed? Why should social change need the intervention of the Supreme Court?

There have been many schemes and programmes for the rehabilitation of safai karamcharis and many high officials, often prime ministers, have spoken out promising to make India free of manual scavenging. Why hasn’t that happened?

*

The changes may be slow, but they are taking place. These are not just at the level of the community and the state, but also the civil society and the media. Responses to manual scavenging from civil society and the media, until some years ago, used to express sympathy but not support or work towards eradication of manual scavenging. Earlier they would say, ‘They don’t have the skills for alternative work’, ‘They should be given better equipment’, and so on. Now, many have joined the SKA movement, endorsing our stand that human beings should not be lifting the excreta of other human beings. That they should come out of this practice into a world of dignity and equality.

Over the years, there have been efforts by many people at many levels, but the biggest effort has to be from us. It is difficult, but most important that we take the initiative in our own hands, leave the work and free India of the scourge of manual scavenging.

9 Comments leave one →
  1. Ammu Abraham permalink
    December 22, 2010 5:00 PM

    A dry latrine inside the Hyderabad high court! Hope they are all gone now and that there will be good rehabilitation and skill training and compensation. All power to the Andolan

  2. December 22, 2010 5:46 PM

    Civil society is active on this issue but speed and intensity of activism need to be fast.Society and individual both should understand that to love cleanness is one thing but to maintain cleanness everyone will have to give extra effort.Self dependency would only gained by breaking the feudalistic mindset and cast hierarchy

  3. a rose cellar permalink
    December 22, 2010 10:54 PM

    more than a decade ago( and the situation has not changed much) ‘The Hindu’ conducted a survey of almost 20 cities( on ecology and environment). apart from other things, such as contaminated water, there was one common phenomenon all over india—lack of sanitation/poor infrastructure to deal with piss and shit. today’s indian express has one headline about the india-russia deal of over 30 billion dollars. for what? fighter jets! the state has no time for piss and shit! there are more serious concerns, more major agendas—to build a military-industrial complex that establishes its rising status on the world scene! piss and shit can be collected by its citizens themselves!!!

  4. a rose cellar permalink
    December 23, 2010 4:36 PM

    if i remember correctly, the survey was conducted in 1995-96. it is really worth reading to comprehend the environmental collapse of indian towns and cities. moreover, it shows exactly what the post says—bureaucrats, ministers, and other officials are not bothered. they have to be informed by people like us!
    or, even more shockingly, if an ecological disaster is pointed out the response is–“this is a minor problem.” of course, the problem has by now become so huge that some other senior bureaucrat has been asked to look into it!
    this sounds straight from a gabriel garcia maquez story—to let the length and breadth of inequality and injustice increase…to such an extent that it all collapses on you…and you emerge out of it saying,” oh! i am fine. nothing happened…,” while there is a debris, a ruin, a pile of piss and shit all around you!

  5. a rose cellar permalink
    December 23, 2010 4:43 PM

    shivam, the full name(correctly written) is: Gabriel José de la Concordia García Márquez

  6. December 23, 2010 10:30 PM

    There should be a way in which the district collectors can be held accountable.

  7. Kumarpushp permalink
    December 24, 2010 8:46 PM

    It is shame for the hindus and their hindu led government who want to become UN member and other side Balmiki communities is being forced to keep manual scavenging alive.Dr Ambedkar was belongs to Balmiki communities ,except maharasthra ,all parts of India ,Balmiki communities are forced to keep manual scaveging alive.one side they buying nuclear reactor from france other side they left dalits to die in hunger.time has come dalit leaderships should join together at global level to make India nacked who are practising manual scavging.Dr Ambedkar had asked dalits not to skin dead animals then Bal ganga dhar Tilak had told the dalits that Dr Ambedkar will make you starved to death because you will not get mony by selling the skin of dead animals.when news came to Dr Ambedkar ,he had advised Mr Tilak ,to ask his community member to skinned the dead animals so your community will get more mony.Now reasponsibility has lies on the shoulder of OM Prakash balmiki to ask balmiki communities not to touch manual scaveging any more.when chamar communities of India had left their jobs and they are still alive and kicking the butt of hindus led government then why cant Balmiki community whose fore father Dr Ambedkar had kicked the butt of hindu led government in India.Long Live Dr ambedkar and his people.

  8. Mukul Dube permalink
    December 24, 2010 9:21 PM

    It seems to me that major hurdles in the way of creating a collective movement must be geographical dispersion and the existence of long established “patron-client” ties.

  9. ajit permalink
    December 25, 2010 6:55 AM

    Kudos to the organisers.

We look forward to your comments. Comments are subject to moderation as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 57,201 other followers

%d bloggers like this: