Skip to content

Do we have the right to a peaceful protest?: Warisha Farasat

February 9, 2013

Guest post by WARISHA FARASAT, who was present at the peaceful Jantar Mantar protest against the execution of Afzal Guru

We have been finally denied even the basic right to a peaceful protest. Two incidents over the last week have proven that only the right wing Hindutva groups have the right to protest in this country; the unbridled right to disrupt all other peaceful protests; and to ensure that the civil liberties groups are pushed even further against the wall. Two days ago, a peaceful student protest against Narendra Modi’s speech at Delhi University was met with brutal response, which has been reported extensively. Today, as Shuddhabrata Sengupta has poignantly pointed in his earlier post there were peaceful silent protests against the secretive hanging of Afzal Guru, and also for the abolition of the death penalty from the criminal statute books at Jantar Mantar. But what unraveled thereafter was shameful. The police watched and participated while young and brave University students, several of them Kashmiri, were beaten up. I saw young women with scarves, which were seen as a marker of their identity being targeted, groped, beaten, humiliated, abused, and finally arrested. Other respected civil liberties activists, lawyers, and even journalists were abused, kicked, beaten, and their faces blackened.

Perhaps it is time that we surrender all our fundamental rights guaranteed under the Indian Constitution since nothing seems to matter any more. Let us voluntarily surrender these rights as the state institutions, and the police are not interested or inclined in protecting peaceful young students or civil society activists, lawyers, journalists or anyone anymore. I was trained in the law. Over the years, I have unpacked facts and evidence, read legal judgments, and tried to understand the justice delivery system.

But, today I do not want to write a long legalistic piece that I usually do because I am so deeply disgusted at how the protestors were treated; and at our “collective helplessness” to do anything about the encouragement provided by the police to the Hindutva right wing assaulters. There are reams and reams of independent citizens inquiries, judges, international and national human rights group reports on the impact of militarization and the deeply entrenched impunity over the past two decades of conflict in Kashmir, if anyone is bothered to read them. Does the rule of law operate in Kashmir?

Can the rule of law framework be selectively used in certain situations and not in others? I came back home to frenetic anchors and discussants on news channels (that have incidentally all been blocked in Kashmir that is under curfew) screaming how the rule of law finally triumphed with Afzal’ s hanging. In fact, the rule of law was deeply wounded not only by the manner of this secretive hanging, but also because individuals were denied their right to protest peacefully. Is there no right to peacefully disagree with the decision of the Supreme Court or with the use of death penalty in India?

I can switch off the TV set but somehow I cannot find a way to turn off the images of the protestors being brutalized and humiliated at Jantar Mantar today.

10 Comments leave one →
  1. February 10, 2013 12:31 AM

    Gradually India has started showing all the symptoms of an Orwellian state:(

    • Mohamad Irfan permalink
      February 10, 2013 10:17 AM

      Dear Sis.. You are realizing it now… we have grew up with this since our childhood.. India is the biggest democracy and I am still with this, but I strongly believe its a biggest democracy on papers only not in action.

  2. Shama Zaidi permalink
    February 10, 2013 11:28 AM

    Maybe the police realising that we are in for another bout of rule by the Hindutva right-wing wish to ingratiate themselves.

  3. Vandana permalink
    February 10, 2013 7:06 PM

    Is this our democracy?
    This question pops up in our minds again and again.
    Is this what any religion would teach us?
    “Hindu, Muslim, Sikh, Isai…sabhi jan ek hai;
    Rang, roop, vesh, bhasha, chahey anek hain.”
    That claim can be discarded if we are giving hate speeches towards any group. Our umbrella of democracy needs to have room for minorities of any type: religious, gender, tribes, caste, financial status…
    Diversity of religion and culture makes a rich resourceful Nation. We need to nurture our resources and respect each others’ freedoms, even for silent protest.
    A strong peoples sense of integratedness cannot be undone by hate speeches or SOTs; whether it is a religion, gender, caste or SES.
    Action: Who we elect next has to be a leader who can cleanse the police force and give them a new ideology of respect for the citizen on the street- minority or not. And, someone who can enforce an effective system for Justice and re-write the books if necessary and give perks for cleaning out the backlog of cases pending. We could have time limits set for different types of cases at each court level, after all.
    As far as women are concerned, I do believe the Indian women are the ones who can emerge as Durga and be Jhansi ki Rani to fight evil even if the evil is male in uniform.
    After disrespecting so many women, no one will commit suicide out of shame because its common occurence, they will eventually group together and be any army of groped women who dont care about threats anymore…they will catch you on the street…on a dark night…with a rod. This is my fear because all human beings reach a point of, “Enough. No more of this.”

    • Connor permalink
      February 11, 2013 7:37 PM

      and indian men should be Chatrapati Shivaji who demolished the irreligious rule of Mughals

  4. Natasha Singh permalink
    February 11, 2013 3:33 PM

    Is there no way of complaining againt police action then? Can we not take inspiration from Ai Wei Wei and document and record all these incidents and make them public so they cannot be denied…can he courts not intervene as the right to peaceful protest is a constitutional right? Unless we can bring the system to book it will continue because we keep on taking it and remaining silent…

Trackbacks

  1. Warisha Farasat’s thoughts on the Feb 9 protests held in opposition to the hanging of Afzal Guru | Centre For Equity Studies
  2. My Problem with the Hanging of Afzal Guru « The Revolution Breathes Fire
  3. Collective Conscience or Collective Vengeance? «

We look forward to your comments. Comments are subject to moderation as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 49,089 other followers

%d bloggers like this: