Skip to content

Through the screen, not so darkly: Raza Rumi

October 18, 2011

Guest post by RAZA RUMI

Pakistanis love Bollywood. There is no question about that. Amidst the love-hate perceptions, Indian cinema has for decades fed public imagination. Before the 1965 war that took place when Ayub Khan, Pakistan’s first military ruler, was in power,  Indian films were released in Pakistan regularly. They competed with the local cinema. The healthy contest enriched filmmaking and gave choice to Pakistani cinema-goers. The war and competing imaginary nationalism halted this process and for decades, Indian films stayed away from cinemas until another military ruler, Parvez Musharraf, allowed limited releases. Such is the power of Bollywood and its commercial viability that for the past few years, Bollywood flicks have revived cinema in Pakistan.

Earlier, Doordarshan, the state-run Indian TV channel, came to the rescue of many Pakistanis who lived close to the border. In Lahore, Doordarshan was viewed with much fascination and when the film Pakeezah was shown on TV, nobody was found on the streets of Lahore. In the late 1970s, the arrival of the Video Cassette Recorder (VCR) filled in the void; and renting/selling Indian videocassettes emerged as a major entrepreneurial opportunity across the country – in cities, small towns and even large villages, video shops were the mainstay of the local economy and culture. I remember from my childhood days how a daily visit to the video rental outlet was an essential part of living.

Despite the hate narratives and the ‘enemy’ status of India, cinematic productions from the other side of the border have stirred interest and fascination. Bollywood has thrived on tragedies, on tales of crime and passion, of police brutality and of course, music. These cultural values are shared by the people of Pakistan. The proclivity for melodrama and ordinary tales is found in Pakistan, too.

The Indian parallel cinema, or what are often described as ‘art films’, was also hugely popular with the urban classes. Ask any one of my generation and they will remember at least 4-5 artsy productions starring Shabana Azmi, Smita Patil, Naseeruddin Shah and Farooq Shaikh. Films such as Mandi, Bhumika, Arth and Manthan are still recalled and discussed. Indians may have forgotten them, we haven’t.

During Musharraf’s rule, Indian films produced or released outside India were allowed public screening in Pakistan. Almost all major Bollywood films arrive in Pakistani cities. The new cineplex model of entertainment has become popular with the elites and middle classes. In Lahore, for instance there are four major cineplexes which show Indian films on a regular basis. In Rawalpindi, otherwise a conservative army-city, the ‘cineplex’ happens to be in a restricted area surrounded by residences and establishments of the Pakistan Army. What could be more ironic than its address: Jinnah Park, Kacheri Road, Rawalpindi Cantonment. Close to the cinema is a McDonald’s outlet – another foreign brand that is hugely popular while its originating country is getting deeply unpopular in Pakistan! The power of profit, they say, overrides emotions and transcends borders. After all China, our mightiest of friends, trades with Taiwan and India.

The downside of Paksitan’s cinema scene is that the local film industry is an etherized patient lying on the Pakistani horizons. It has a great past with stars such as Noor Jehan, singers such as Mehdi Hasan and Runa Laila and memorable stories that would have been forgotten had they not found a new life via Youtube.

However, a clutch of films in the last five years have proved that there is sufficient potential and even an eager market within Pakistan. Shoaib Mansoor, originally associated with Pakistan’s television industry directed Khuda Ke Liye in 2007 and his recent film Bol has stunned everyone including Indian audiences. ‘Khuda Ke Liye’ was also critically acclaimed and won the Silver Pyramid Award at the Cairo International Film Festival (2007) and was shown across the globe with its rather chilling account of 9/11. The film was replete with voices against bigotry and retrogressive forces and found much resonance with Pakistanis.

‘Bol’ is a different film altogether. It deals with the cloistered existence of women in old Lahore and weaves a pretty complex plot typifying Pakistan’s (and by extension South Asian) prejudices against women, transvestites, prostitution, casteism among others. It has an overt empowering message that some critics have found a little over the top, especially the woman protagonist hysterical speeches. However, it works for South Asian sensibilities where a bit of drama and noise is not frowned upon.

It has been reported that Bol despite its relatively low budget, has done pretty well in India. In Pakistan, it remains popular two months after its release. There is another story in this experience. Indians can know Pakistan better through its cinema and television. Once upon a time, a few Pakistani plays were quite popular in north India where Hindi/Urdu is understood. In recent decades, Pakistan is largely seen through the prism of the mainstream corporate media. And this has not helped. Stereotypes about Pakistan are commonly sold in the media, leading many to believe that Pakistan is a failed state where men roam around with Kalashinkovs and women cannot leave homes without a burqa, that  it is a paradise of jihadis and Lashkars. The truth is far from these constructs. It is just another country, in many ways similar to India for its diversity, inequities and contradictions and conflicts. India is bigger, more democratic and has a huge middle class. Pakistan is catching up.

Another amazing film that united the people of Pakistan and India was Khamosh Pani, directed by Sabiha Sumar. It dealt with the tragedy of Partition and mixed identities. The locale was Punjab but the post-partition trajectory of events is moving and symbolic of what happened on a larger scale: rise of extremist ideologies, unresolved and unhealed wounds of 1947 and commonality of human aspirations on both the sides.

India and Pakistan will have to break the iron curtains of communication. They will need to exchange films, give landing rights to TV channels and act like responsible sixty-four year olds and not quarrelling adolescents. The direction that cinema has shown has should not be lost.

(Raza Rumi is a writer, editor and policy adviser based in Pakistan. He tweets as @razarumi. This article first appeared in Kindle magazine.

From Kafila archives:

See also:

7 Comments leave one →
  1. October 18, 2011 5:31 PM

    “Indians may have forgotten them, we haven’t.” YES!!!!

  2. shama zaidi permalink
    October 18, 2011 9:02 PM

    nice thought raza saheb, especially as the mumbai film festival is on and almost every screening is full. we have iranian, turkish, sri lankan, egyptian, chinese films but nothing from pakistan. i saw bol in bangalore and it was the second week and so there were not many in the audience, but it was appreciated.

  3. October 18, 2011 9:06 PM

    Hello, this is tangential to the excellent article:
    I have two reservations re the words “responsible sixty-four year olds and not quarrelling adolescents” in the last two lines

    1. Alas not all people past a certain age are worthy of your approval, you would readily agree, I’m sure: Witness Narendra Modi and his ilk among the Indian politicos, Dick Cheney, Rummy, Berlusconi, Kim Jong-il, Robert Mugabe, Gaddafi…

    2. The maturity or otherwise of countries, civilizations and religions needs perhaps to be measured using a different yardstick than that for humans.
    Afterall the Westphalian nation-state has been around for centuries and some countries have played according to those rules for a lot longer than the recent (and thus more fanatical) converts to that model.

  4. Voyeur permalink
    October 18, 2011 11:45 PM

    Bol, Khamosh Pani are all message type films which, while interesting are not pure entertainment films. We should organize a screening of Maula Jatt series in India. The versions I downloaded from the internet are incomplete. But if a new one were to be made in the Maula Jatt-Noorie Nutt series, it would give the ‘Singham’s and ‘Bodyguard’s a run for their money.


  1. Giving democracy in Pakistan a chance: Raza Rumi « Kafila
  2. Trading with the Enemy: Raza Rumi « Kafila
  3. Pakistan 2012 – We Must Learn from History: Raza Rumi « Kafila

We look forward to your comments. Comments are subject to moderation as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 71,862 other followers

%d bloggers like this: