Skip to content

Qateel Siddiqi killed in Judicial Custody – Who is Responsible?

June 8, 2012

This public statement comes via Manisha Sethi; see full list of signatories at the end.

Twenty-seven year old Qateel Siddiqi, arrested in November 2011 by the Special Cell for his alleged Indian Mujahideen links, has been killed in Yerwada Central jail in Pune today. The murder has ostensibly been carried out fellow inmates for unknown reasons. Qateel had been shifted to Yerwada only a few days ago after the Maharashtra ATS had taken his custody for a test identification parade.

Qateel’s killing raises several important questions:

– Siddiqi was kept in high security anda jail and not in the common barracks. How then did the attack take place?

– Could the attack have taken place without the complicity, even if passive, of the Yerwada jail authorities?

– Given the claim of the investigating agencies that Qateel was the key to unraveling the IM network, what happens now to those investigations?

– The fact that Siddiqi was to be moved out of the Yerwada Jail and was eliminated just before that smacks of a conspiracy.

While custodial violence is endemic and almost institutionalized, Maharashtra Jails are also notorious for attacks on accused, particularly on those accused of terrorism. The brutal violence unleashed on the Mumbai train blasts accused in the Arthur Road jail three years ago, at the behest of the jail authorities, comes immediately to mind. It is obvious that undertrials, especially those charged with crimes like terrorism, are not safe in Maharashtra jails.

All accused in judicial custody are directly under the care of the judiciary and as such it is the judiciary’s responsibility to ensure their well-being and safety.  We hope therefore that the Mumbai High Court will take suo moto notice of this killing and initiate action in the matter.

We demand that:

1)   An FIR under section 302 be filed immediately for the Killing of Qateel Siddiqi

2)    Compensation should be granted to the wife of Qateel Siddiqi for his killing in judicial custody

3)   An impartial enquiry should be constituted to investigate into the killing.

Further, the dead body of Qateel Siddiqi must be transported for his burial to his hometown at the cost of the Maharashtra State, given also that the family is too poor to bear the expenses.


Manisha Sethi, Sanghamitra Misra, Ahmed Sohaib, Adeel Mehdi, Tanweer Fazal (for JTSA)

Shabnam Hashmi and Bhawna Sharma (for ANHAD)

Colin Gonsalves, Harsh Dobhal and Mahtab Alam (for HRLN)

3 Comments leave one →
  1. June 8, 2012 11:52 PM

    The terrorist state is as obvious as day!!

  2. June 9, 2012 4:29 PM

    Every citizen deserves safety. Accused ones too. There are however limits to the safety that the state can provide. Terrorism evokes brutal responses too from the lay public when they can. It is, no doubt, a mob justice. There is difference between convicted terrorists and those accused of terrorism. Till proved guilty, one is innocent. There ought to be a via media between spending crores for Kasab, the 26/11 accused and those accused of lesser terrorist crimes or those who are Indian citizens. There is a danger of someone being branded as a terrorist and then disposed off by fellow prisoners. i do not know this particular case but some counselling to accused persons to keep calm under provocation could be done so that they themselves do not contribute to their own lynching. While high security jails may not always be feasible, some measures, not too costly, but adequate for safety could be adopted. Jailers know how they could do this if they apply their mind to it. An abrupt ending of an accused person’s life thwarts justice that could go either way. .


  1. Text of the letter to P. Chidambaram by citizens’ group « kracktivist

We look forward to your comments. Comments are subject to moderation as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 71,864 other followers

%d bloggers like this: