Skip to content

A Government in Hiding

December 23, 2012

Protestors from Raisina Hill began to be forcibly removed late last night. The police action continued in the foggy cold of this December morning. Aghast at the violence on a completely peaceful gathering of students – some of them just school children – many of us too felt compelled to join the demonstrations. A number of left-wing student groups who have been part of the protests had called for collecting at the Neel Gumbaz at Nizamuddin. At 11 am, we all started collecting there – many of us older folk going there in solidarity with what has been one of the most unprecedented student-youth mobilizations in the city. Yesterday, there had been repeated rounds of  water cannons, tear-gas and brutal lathi-charge by the police of a government that has gone into hiding.

Finally, some 600-700 of us began moving in a procession from Nizamuddin to India Gate. When we reached there, we discovered that already large numbers of people had begun recongregating at ‘Rajpath’ – the Power Avenue where every January the Republic displays its military might to the world. The numbers were continuously swelling. A group of supporters of Arvind Kejriwal’s AAP – inclduing Kejriwal and other leaders – were squatting on one side, towards Hyderabad House. This was virtually on the margins of the area where the main crowds were. Apart from the group of people we had come with, there were hundreds who seemed to us to be completely unaffiliated ordinary students, contrary to some claims floating around in Facebook that these were ‘RSS crowds’. At one end a human chain had been erected and slogan shouting for justice continued. Around the Amar Jawan Jyoti, there were processsions of students still coming in. We were there till about 2 pm and there was no question of any violence at all – except for three unprovoked tear gas shells that had been lobbed by the police into the crowd. There had been some minor commotion as the police occassionally tried to push back students with a lathi charge of sorts.

By this time, however, it was apparent that the police was preparing for the offensive. Police briefings were taking place in different groups and gradually the crowd was being surrounded from all sides. And yet, till about 2.50 pm, despite twenty rounds of tear gas being fired by the police, as well as periodic lathi charges  – they did not manage to provoke violence from the crowd to justify a crackdown. But the crackdown had to take place. And lo and behold, the justifications for it materialized, suspiciously, very soon. Bonojit Hussain sent this update after the round of violent eviction of the protestors:

Just back from India Gate. Police crackdown through out the day was severe with endless rounds of tear gas shelling, baton and water canon charges. But what was more disturbing was that as the day progressed, the protest was taken over by mob. It was height of lumpenism; several women protesters were molested; sexist slogans overtook slogans for gender justice; watch towers were put on fire and vehicles overturned. It can be summed by an oxymoron – “Machismo and Testosterone against Rape”.

So, who were these people who suddenly materialized and took over the protest area in exactly the way that the police wanted them to? Who were these people who gave the police the much needed alibi alongside their display of sexist machismo? It is highly unlikely that they were ‘protestors’. There is only one word for such elements who surface repeatedly in the history of mass movements: agent provocateurs. Some people seem to have identified them as NSUI elements. Perhaps there were some others too like ABVP, but it seems most likely that they were the stormtroopers of the Congress party.

When we got back home, most reports on television too uderlined the fact that there had been a violent police attack on utterly peaceful protestors. Of all the footage that I could see, I did not see a single one where the ‘lumpens’ were being beaten and attacked. They had done their work and conveniently moved to a safe distance from where they continued to pelt stones but the police made no attempt to get them. Apart from the pro-Congress NDTV and the somewhat chastized CNN-IBN, most of the others clearly showed that the police violence was entirely one-sided.

One more thing needs to be stated clearly, especially for the benefit of those misled by the die-hard left-wing and other assorted cynics. Yes there were slogans about ‘death penalty’ and ‘castration’ but there were as many slogans that asserted different viewpoints – ‘Take Back the Night’, ‘Don’t teach your daughter not to go out; Teach  your son to behave properly’; ‘Mere skirt se oonchi meri awaz hai’.  And not all those who raise demands for ‘death penalty’ are incorrigible rightists – these are just young people spontaneously expressing their anger. So, for instance, when one of us got into a conversation with a group of students who were raising this slogan and explained why feminists have a problem with such a demand, they listened attentively. Not only did they listen; they were actually open to seeing the other point of view. [In any case, we might do well to remember that the question of capital punishment is not a settled issue among ‘Leftists’ either – many of whom pass off summary executions in China in complete silence!].

Finally, a small point about the demands of the movement. Unfortunately, our imagination still does not go beyond demanding new laws. That is our most common and unthought response to any crisis. And that is why the Home Minister could take us for a ride by promising a stringent law that would provide for death penbalty in “the rarest of rare rape cases” – whatever that means. The fact that there are no convictions in rape cases has nothing to do with lack of stringency of the law. It has everything to do with rampant patriarchal values in the very processes of the law, where every rape trial becomes a farcical replay of the rape, as if it is the raped woman who is on trial.

But most importantly, low conviction rate in rape cases has everything to do with the police. First, it has to do with the fact that the police refuses to even register FIRs in a majority of rape cases. The woman who goes to a police station to register an FIR is most likely to face more humiliation there.  More stringent laws will only give more powers to an already corrupt and brutal police force to harass ordinary people, frame innocents and let the culprits go scot free.

Perhaps this is the time to look beyond mere demand for new laws and to focus on the decrepit and corrupt entity that the police force is. It is the police that should be the target of our exertions right now. The Police force in Delhi – as indeed in the rest of the country – needs to be thoroughly revamped in terms of training, accountability and gender sensitivity.


More from Kafila:

26 December:

25 December

24 December

23 December

13 Comments leave one →
  1. Vig Yani permalink
    December 24, 2012 12:01 AM

    Current entire political class and various state elements (including highly paid by tax payer’s money, increasingly ineffective bureaucracy) are not capable or competent to lead younger India. They cannot even understand younger India’s aspirations and hence do not know how to react to more aware and empowered younger India. Younger India can’t be stopped by brute force and if this political dispension does not change then it will lead to chaos.

    Indian police force any where in India is a legacy of colonial times, a monster that was created to brutalise and control ‘natives’ and unfortunately it continues that way. So police brutality does not surprise me so much but what surprises is that it remains the same way even after so long we attained so called ‘Independence’.
    What surprises me more that so called IIT educated Babus plan and carry out such brutality. Delhi police is just an instrument in hands of home ministry of the Union Government.

  2. December 24, 2012 12:40 AM

    So thankful that you and Shudhhabrata aren’t taking the cynical way out and branding this a middle class kneejerk response and instead recognizing the protest’s honesty and ernestness.

  3. December 24, 2012 10:05 AM

    other measures we can consider to make our cities safe for women:

    1. allocating 50% of auto rickshaw driver licenses to women drivers.
    2. employing more women conductors in state owned public transport buses, like in Bangalore. infact all bus conductors can be women.
    3. online FIRs. if police refuse to register an FIR, people should be able to file it online instead of having to run from police commissioner, courts to lokayuktas. its understandable that police stations will refuse to register FIR, to show low crime levels in their circle. hence the need for online FIRs.
    4. employing more women in the police force. Tamilnadu has Women only police stations besides a Yellow Bridage police which patrols to identify public sexual harassment of women (stop calling it eve teasing).
    5. removing restrictions on auto-rickshaw/bus ownership in cities so that large corporations own the fleet and hence can be held accountable for the quality of drivers they employ.
    6. abolishing all special courts including proposed fast-track courts for rape! why should a bail application of a corrupt politician get higher priority than a dowry harassment or rape? why should trials in CBI and corruption related cases be held fast in special courts while ordinary people wait for years in regular courts? special courts hurt the common people by diverting resources to few ‘popular’ cases. its the lack of fear of punishment in minor cases that makes criminals dare to rape. not the delay in conviction in a corruption case. let the corrupt serve more time in judicial custody awaiting trial, than wasting the courts time applying for bail.

  4. a_leftist permalink
    December 24, 2012 10:33 AM

    China is no more a ‘leftist’ country. If the author had his ear on the contemporary intellectual ground, he would have known that if there is one country fully embracing capitalism, it is China. And just because a ‘leftist’ country has capital punishment, that does not mean that leftists everywhere support death penalty. Such narrow views are a sign of right-winged thinking, not the leftists.

  5. R S Thapar permalink
    December 24, 2012 7:51 PM

    The violence on Sunday by police is said to be a reaction to the violence of the protestors. But then why did the police beat up people on saturday ? The Congress wanted to defame the movement but has not succeeded.

  6. December 25, 2012 11:36 AM

    i think it’s a Time for present government to Resign and ask for the Fresh Mandate of the People as it has lost it’s Credibility totally not within the Country but also Internationally.History speak that no king has ever Survived with the help of DANDA.
    PM’S appeal on TV qouting ref that He too has three daughters didn’t sound good as her daughters r having 24 hours security.


  1. Delhi protests live: PM appeals for calm, victim still critical | Firstpost
  2. Delhi Protesters had to be engaged, heard, and spoken to... instead they were Lathi charged! |
  3. On the #Delhiprotests, Social Change and Public Innovation |
  4. Bakht Arif, from Pakistan, sings Zinda Lash for Patronizing Indian Politicians (No, Don’t Listen to Honey Singh) « Kafila

We look forward to your comments. Comments are subject to moderation as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 71,928 other followers

%d bloggers like this: